Milwaukee Brewers: Grading Brew Crew's Past Trades

Doug Melvin, the Milwaukee Brewers general manager, is considered one of baseball's best. He slowly but surely brought the team from the pit of the NL Central to the throne in 2011. The question is, however: Is he really that good a general manager?

Melvin has done a lot to improve the Brewers, that much is certain. But he has also made some questionable moves that no one seems to be talking about.

I'm going to examine four trades that Melvin has made in the past five years. You be the judge.

Is Doug Melvin an overrated general manager?